QThe UK’s Daily Mail reports that an estimated 125,000 farmers have committed suicide because of crop failure and massive debt since planting GM seeds. I have watched a tv show on this and was wondering how Monsanto feels about this. Its supposed to he

The UK’s Daily Mail reports that an estimated 125,000 farmers have committed suicide because of crop failure and massive debt since planting GM seeds. I have watched a tv show on this and was wondering how Monsanto feels about this. Its supposed to help farmers but it seems to be wiping out the little guy. Is this seem right?

AExpert Answer

Like everyone else at Monsanto, when I hear about suicide, I feel the same way you do – my heart breaks. Suicide is an awful, tragic waste no matter where or why it occurs. But the sorrow and hopelessness that leads someone to take his own life is complicated. Trying to attribute it to a single cause – especially when you’re talking about lots of different people – is misleading. And let me be clear – planting GM seeds is not the cause of the farmer suicide problem in India.

 

Suicide has been a problem in the Indian farming community for a long time, since well before the first GM crops (specifically, cotton) were introduced in 2002. The fact is, farming in India is very, very hard.  There is a set of systemic and social issues that can lead to hopelessness among farmers, which has in turn led to suicides. 

It’s important to look for the root causes of Indian farmer suicides in order to find solutions. Numerous international organizations have been doing just that. Their research has shown that the suicide problem is complex, and that it is not the result of planting GM seeds. 

 

For instance, a June 2012 study from the Canadian non-profit Council for Social Development found that GM cotton has benefited Indian farmers, both in terms of yield and more generally in terms of quality of life. Rather than GM crops, this study identified the key reasons leading to farmer suicides as lack of irrigation facilities, unavailability of timely credit and fluctuating cotton prices over the years.

 

A 2008 study by the International Food Policy Research Institute found indebtedness among Indian farmers can be linked to numerous causes including a lack of reliable credit, changes in government policies, cropping patterns, plant and insect resistance to pesticides, and even shifts in the crops planted on the farm.

 

Some other studies include: “Measuring the Contribution of Bt Cotton Adoption to India’s Cotton Yields Leap,” International Food Policy Research Institute Discussion Paper 01170, Guillaume P Gruere, Yan Sun; Economic impacts and impact dynamics of Bt (Bacillus thuringiensis) cotton in India, Proceedings of the National Academies of Science, May 15, 2012; and Indira Gandhi Institute of Development Research Study: Suicide of Farmers in Maharashtra (January 2006).

 

Finally, I hope it’s okay if I address this personally. I have worked with cotton farmers since I was in college decades ago. I have traveled to places off the map throughout the U.S. and on visits to several foreign countries, including India, through both work and personal vacations. I’m proud to be part of an organization that is trying to help these farmers improve their situations.

Posted on March 8, 2018
GMOs will not “save the world,” however they are an important tool in the toolbox for food security and agriculture. Dr. Stuart Smyth, Assistant Professor in the Department of Bioresource Policy, Business and Economics at the University of Saskatchewan, explores this topic in depth in a similar question and response here. “No single crop or food production method is capable of feeding the world on its own, so no, GMOs by themselves will not feed the world. However, as part... Read More
Answer:
Posted on March 8, 2018
GMOs are made to achieve a desired trait, such as resistance to an insect or improvement to the ripening process, in order to better meet a customer’s needs. Posted below is a five minute video that offers a great visual illustration on how GMOs are made:     In this response you will also find videos demonstrating genetic modification, showing the basic process for making GM plants. We also encourage you to check out the videos: How Are GMOs Created? and GMO... Read More
Posted on November 27, 2017
Thank you for your question. Similar questions have been answered by a variety of experts on our site. Farmer Mary Mertz answered a similar question, “What are the problems with the seeds of GMOs.” She explains how this question can be answered in a variety of ways and also speaks to this topic firsthand, as she is a farmer herself. “In my opinion, the biggest problem with the seeds is the amount of misinformation that is being circulated out there.  GMOs have a... Read More

Explore More Topics