QWhy does Monsanto feel it is necessary to threaten and intimidate farmers, like Mr. Schmieser and other farmers in Canada and the US?

Why does Monsanto feel it is necessary to threaten and intimidate farmers, like Mr. Schmieser and other farmers in Canada and the US?

AExpert Answer

Farmers are our customers, and our goal in all our dealings with farmers is to treat them with a high degree of integrity, respect and transparency.  We work hard to breed and grow seeds that help farmers produce abundant and healthy food. We also work hard to earn the trust of our farmer customers, and we’re honored when they choose to buy and plant our seeds.

 

Like many companies that sell high-value seed, we ask farmers to plant our seeds only once, and if they like them, to buy new seeds for their next planting. If you think about it, the way we sell seed is really no different than the way most of us purchase a phone, computer software, or credit card – the purchase and use of these products comes with an agreement specifying certain terms of use. Farmers have many different seed choices, they understand the value of different types of seeds, they are very smart in making the best choices for each field that they farm, and they freely sign an agreement if they choose to purchase specific seeds.

 

The vast majority of our farmer customers stick to their agreements, but some don’t.  This gives them an unfair advantage over other farmers, because everyone else is paying for technology that they’re getting for free. That is not fair to farmers, and when we ask our farmer customers about this, more than 90% tell us they expect us to keep farming fair for everyone.

 

When cases like Mr. Schmeiser’s are brought to our attention, we follow a strict set of ethical and transparency guidelines that you can view on our web site.  It is very rare for these situations to end up in court, and it is a last resort that we pursue with farmers who have intentionally planted seeds they did not purchase.  We have never sued a farmer when trace amounts of our seeds or traits were present in a farmer’s field as an accident or as a result of inadvertent means such as cross pollination.  We have publically made that commitment. 

 

Regarding your reference to Mr. Schmeiser, several courts (including the Canadian Supreme Court) have affirmed that he violated our patent.  As indicated by the trial court in Canada, the seed was not blown in on the wind nor carried in by birds, and it didn’t spontaneously appear. Schmeiser knowingly planted this seed in his field without permission or license. By doing so, he used Monsanto’s patented technology without permission. In fact, the courts determined this in three separate decisions.  More detailed information regarding the situation with Mr. Schmeiser is available on our website if you are interested in additional information.

Posted on September 20, 2017
“Everyone is entitled to his own opinion, but not his own facts.” Daniel Patrick Moynihan.    GMO Answers provides the facts that answer questions related to biotechnology, GM crops and agriculture. We work to ensure that the content and answers provided by experts and companies is accurate and therefore do not present opinions about GMOs, simply facts. GMO Answers is a community focused on constructive discussion about GMOs in order to have open conversations about... Read More
Answer:
Posted on September 5, 2017
While there might be some institutions with the capability to make these transgenic watermelon and coconut plants for you, that does not mean that you would be able to actually plant them out. First, the institution would need to have a Biological Use Authorization to work with recombinant DNA to make the vectors to transfer the genes. Then they would need to be able to do the tissue culture required to transfer the genes and regenerate whole plants again, which can sometimes be difficult.... Read More
Posted on June 19, 2017
Yes, the EU is one of the geographies where GM-derived food and animal feed must be labeled according to conditions outlined by the European Commission on this webpage. GM labels are very common on sacks of animal feed. Depending on the type of animal, GM labeled feed is often the standard – except of course when it comes to GM free or organic supply chains. Read More
Answer: