QWhat are the breeding obstacles to releasing GMO traits in hybrid seed? What are the performance liability issues related to same, and what are the regulatory issues related to such a release into the environment?

What are the breeding obstacles to releasing GMO traits in hybrid seed? What are the performance liability issues related to same, and what are the regulatory issues related to such a release into the environment?

AExpert Answer

First, thank you very much for your series of questions.  In terms of regulatory issues for releasing transgenic cultivars that are hybrid (such as corn or maize), versus, I assume, ones that are not (such as soybeans), there are no formal differences in the regulatory process. Questions concerning the nature of the gene, its function, its insertion site in the host genome, effect on plant growth and composition, allergenic properties of the added protein, etc., must be satisfied before the transgene can be “deregulated” and used commercially. 

Your question may be getting at the fact that we normally associate hybrid commercial plants with ones that normally outcross in nature, versus ones that normally self-pollinate.  In corn, for example, the female and male flowers are separate and pollen from one plant will commonly pollinate an egg born on a different plant. In contrast, soybeans and many other plants have perfect flowers, and the amount of “outcrossing” in male-fertile soybeans is virtually zero.  Soybean seeds result from a fusion of a sperm and egg produced on the same plant.


The distance of pollen flow and rates of outcrossing are considered in testing of regulated, experimental transgenic plants not yet commercialized.  In corn, for example, experimental transgenic corn must be separated by 660 feet from other conventional corn.  This distance greatly minimizes the amount of transgenic pollen fertilizing neighboring corn.

Questions of liability of transgenic crops are complex, and I refer you to a nice overview by Drew Kershen, 2004, Crop Science volume 44, pages 456-463.  Kershen makes a number of points that perhaps are relevant to this discussion. First, patenting of plant cultivars was ongoing long before biotechnology.  In my view, this fact seems to be forgotten in many current discussions. Second, organic growers do not lose their organic certification for the presence of transgenic plant materials. Perhaps this reflects the fact that pollen flow occurs naturally in agricultural environments.  While we can minimize it, we can never totally block it.

The third point of relevance here is the zero tolerance of many international markets for transgenic plants.  This produces an interesting balancing act of protecting international markets on the one hand but, at the same time, blocking farmers from benefiting from the advantageous effects of transgenic technology. Hopefully this will be resolved in a rational manner in the future.

The discussion of being able to bring legal action against a person for the pollen produced by their plants raises an interesting question:   If I were allergic to ragweed pollen and I was exposed to this pollen while visiting my nearby U-pick organic vegetable grower, could I sue the grower?

Posted on July 21, 2017
GMOs aren't really added directly to the meat, beef.  However, beef cattle may consume feed that comes from a genetically modified plant. All beef cattle begin their lives on a farm or ranch, grazing pasture or grass - none of which is considered a GMO. For many cows this will be their sole source of feed for their lifetime. Some cattle receive rations of grain, which may contain corn or soybeans, both of which have genetically modified hybrids and varieties. ... Read More
Posted on March 28, 2017
Thanks for the question, which I will address in two ways here.   1. What are three ways that organisms are modified by scientists? Here I will focus only on plants.   a. Agrobacterium: Agrobacterium tumefaciens (Agro) is a naturally occurring soil organism that causes a disease in plants called crown gall disease. In the late 1970s, Mary-Dell Chilton discovered that Agro actually transfers genes (DNA) from the Agro to the plant cell, where it becomes integrated into the plant... Read More
Posted on March 2, 2017
First of all, to clarify – hybridization is part of conventional breeding and conventional breeding uses hybridization to create new combinations of genes from parent varieties. For example, a disease-resistant wheat variety may be hybridized to a variety that makes flour better suited for making whole wheat bread. This is a common goal of most conventional breeding programs. It typically involves taking pollen from one parent and using it to fertilize another parent. The... Read More