QShould farmers be compensated for infecting their organic or non-gmo crops with GMO? Should you have to pay the damages to their farm?

Should farmers be compensated for infecting their organic or non-gmo crops with GMO? Should you have to pay the damages to their farm?

AExpert Answer

This is a question that has been seriously scrutinized and debated for a few years now. In 2011, the USDA formed an Advisory Committee on Biotechnology and 21st Century Agriculture to discuss issues of this type. The final report submitted by the committee, in November 2012, did not reach a definitive consensus on how compensation should be handled, if at all. However, it did make some recommendations in terms of stewardship practices and examining the use of crop insurance as a means to protect farmers’ commodity assets.

 

You can read the entire report here (pages 9–14 address compensation):

 

www.usda.gov/documents/ac21_report-enhancing-coexistence.pdf

 

Interestingly enough, the USDA has created an extended period for public comment on the issue of coexistence between various farm production types and compensation, through March 4, 2014. All aspects of the agricultural industry believe that this subject merits discussion and a plan of action so that all parties are protected and receive fair market value for their crops.

 

My husband and I farm in Kansas. We grow both GMO and non-GMO crops. My understanding is that the National Organic Program does allow a presence of GMO traits within organic crops as long as the organic farmer has met the required qualifications and regulations to reach certification. To date, there has never been an instance in which an organic farm has lost its certification because of cross-pollination with GMOs. 

 

I have heard, however, that there have been some cases where grain has been rejected by a buyer because the amount of GMO traits exceeds the contractual agreement. The problem lies in identifying and determining how the field was, in fact, compromised. There are actually various ways in which this could occur, e.g., the seed purchased could have been mixed with biotech seed, or residue could remain in equipment or storage facilities that haven’t been properly cleaned.

 

When grain is taken to market, it is tested and measured for certain criteria. The USDA allows a set level of GMO traits to exist within an organic crop without losing its certification status. If a buyer should refuse to purchase organic grain because of a higher level of biotech presence, the organic farmer can still sell his crop into the conventional market.

 

Personally, we have neighbors who farm 100 percent organically. We have cornfields that are adjacent to one another. For example, with field corn, most organic farmers usually plant two to four weeks later than conventional farmers (because of a different weed control system), and, consequently, pollination periods don’t match up.

 

Organic and conventional farmers are all in the food production business together. We need to work together and respect each other’s farming practices. This entails communication, heightened awareness of weather conditions and being solution oriented to prevent problems from occurring in the first place.

Posted on March 8, 2018
GMOs will not “save the world,” however they are an important tool in the toolbox for food security and agriculture. Dr. Stuart Smyth, Assistant Professor in the Department of Bioresource Policy, Business and Economics at the University of Saskatchewan, explores this topic in depth in a similar question and response here. “No single crop or food production method is capable of feeding the world on its own, so no, GMOs by themselves will not feed the world. However, as part... Read More
Answer:
Posted on March 8, 2018
GMOs are made to achieve a desired trait, such as resistance to an insect or improvement to the ripening process, in order to better meet a customer’s needs. Posted below is a five minute video that offers a great visual illustration on how GMOs are made:     In this response you will also find videos demonstrating genetic modification, showing the basic process for making GM plants. We also encourage you to check out the videos: How Are GMOs Created? and GMO... Read More
Posted on November 27, 2017
Thank you for your question. Similar questions have been answered by a variety of experts on our site. Farmer Mary Mertz answered a similar question, “What are the problems with the seeds of GMOs.” She explains how this question can be answered in a variety of ways and also speaks to this topic firsthand, as she is a farmer herself. “In my opinion, the biggest problem with the seeds is the amount of misinformation that is being circulated out there.  GMOs have a... Read More

Explore More Topics