Line 4Line 4 Copyic/close/grey600play_circle_outline - material

Answers

Question

Do neonicotinoids and Roundup affect the wild bee populations? If so, how are you working to stop this bee killoff?

Submitted by: Forward March


Answer

Expert response from Bill Reeves

Global Health and Safety Issues Management Lead, Bayer Crop Science

Wednesday, 01/10/2014 17:23

Like all companies that produce seed for crops that require insect pollination, Monsanto is concerned about honey bee health. Both our vegetable-seed business and our alfalfa-seed business rely on healthy pollinators to be productive. With respect to the question about possible impacts of Roundup herbicide on honey bees, there is sufficient information to conclude that Roundup herbicide and its active ingredient, glyphosate, do not cause adverse effects in honey bees.

 

In addition to toxicity testing conducted in support of regulatory submissions to the Environmental Protection Agency that demonstrated glyphosate is practically nontoxic to honey bees through both oral and contact exposure, a 2014 publication by Thompson et al. found no adverse effects on adult bees or their young when they were fed environmentally realistic concentrations of glyphosate.

 

In Thompson et al., the authors describe a method for determining hive level glyphosate exposures to bees and used those exposure data to select doses for a follow-up brood study. (For honey bee colonies, the brood is the immature larval bees raised by the adults.) In phase one, bees from four colonies were allowed to feed on glyphosate-treated purple tansy for seven days. Glyphosate levels were measured in nectar and pollen collected by the bees, as well as in the hive. These concentrations were then used in phase two to assess toxicity to the brood by feeding hives glyphosate in a sucrose solution over seven days. Thompson et al. considered survival of eggs, young larvae and old larvae, as well as pupae weight. No adverse effects on adult bees or bee-brood development were observed in any of the glyphosate‐treated colonies.

 

Honey bees face many challenges, and solving them will require addressing many possible causes. Recently, a group of interested parties representing bee keepers, honey producers, academics, agricultural companies and government agencies formed the Honey Bee Health Coalition to identify ways to improve honey bee health. The group is working on four areas: forage and nutrition, hive management, crop pest management and outreach. Please visit the link to learn more about the coalition and the solutions it’s pursuing.

Answer

Expert response from Iain Kelley

Director, Regulatory Policy and Issue Management, Bayer Crop Science

Friday, 01/08/2014 10:55

The Environmental Protection Agency’s (EPA’s) Pesticide Registration Process is designed to assess that pesticides used according to label directions do not pose any unreasonable adverse effects to either native or managed bees. Recent guidelines from EPA, Canada’s Pest Management Regulatory Agency (PMRA) and California’s Department of Pesticide Regulation (CDPR) define this process under which neonicotinoids continue to be assessed. In 2007, the National Academy of Science issued an extensive study, “Status of Pollinators in North America,” highlighting the central role that habitat has in maintaining native bee populations, and more recent publications support this. The crop protection industry has numerous activities ongoing to encourage the planting of more pollinator-friendly plants and research into plant species attractive to native pollinators. Extensive studies on honey bees (which are not native pollinators but are a useful indicator species) show that labeled uses of neonicotinoids do not impact bee-colony health. Although less research has been conducted on other pollinators, studies on bumblebees and leaf-cutting bees have shown that neonicotinoid applications can be safely used without harming these important pollinators.

Answer

Expert response from Bill Reeves

Global Health and Safety Issues Management Lead, Bayer Crop Science

Wednesday, 01/10/2014 17:23

Like all companies that produce seed for crops that require insect pollination, Monsanto is concerned about honey bee health. Both our vegetable-seed business and our alfalfa-seed business rely on healthy pollinators to be productive. With respect to the question about possible impacts of Roundup herbicide on honey bees, there is sufficient information to conclude that Roundup herbicide and its active ingredient, glyphosate, do not cause adverse effects in honey bees.

 

In addition to toxicity testing conducted in support of regulatory submissions to the Environmental Protection Agency that demonstrated glyphosate is practically nontoxic to honey bees through both oral and contact exposure, a 2014 publication by Thompson et al. found no adverse effects on adult bees or their young when they were fed environmentally realistic concentrations of glyphosate.

 

In Thompson et al., the authors describe a method for determining hive level glyphosate exposures to bees and used those exposure data to select doses for a follow-up brood study. (For honey bee colonies, the brood is the immature larval bees raised by the adults.) In phase one, bees from four colonies were allowed to feed on glyphosate-treated purple tansy for seven days. Glyphosate levels were measured in nectar and pollen collected by the bees, as well as in the hive. These concentrations were then used in phase two to assess toxicity to the brood by feeding hives glyphosate in a sucrose solution over seven days. Thompson et al. considered survival of eggs, young larvae and old larvae, as well as pupae weight. No adverse effects on adult bees or bee-brood development were observed in any of the glyphosate‐treated colonies.

 

Honey bees face many challenges, and solving them will require addressing many possible causes. Recently, a group of interested parties representing bee keepers, honey producers, academics, agricultural companies and government agencies formed the Honey Bee Health Coalition to identify ways to improve honey bee health. The group is working on four areas: forage and nutrition, hive management, crop pest management and outreach. Please visit the link to learn more about the coalition and the solutions it’s pursuing.

Answer

Expert response from Iain Kelley

Director, Regulatory Policy and Issue Management, Bayer Crop Science

Friday, 01/08/2014 10:55

The Environmental Protection Agency’s (EPA’s) Pesticide Registration Process is designed to assess that pesticides used according to label directions do not pose any unreasonable adverse effects to either native or managed bees. Recent guidelines from EPA, Canada’s Pest Management Regulatory Agency (PMRA) and California’s Department of Pesticide Regulation (CDPR) define this process under which neonicotinoids continue to be assessed. In 2007, the National Academy of Science issued an extensive study, “Status of Pollinators in North America,” highlighting the central role that habitat has in maintaining native bee populations, and more recent publications support this. The crop protection industry has numerous activities ongoing to encourage the planting of more pollinator-friendly plants and research into plant species attractive to native pollinators. Extensive studies on honey bees (which are not native pollinators but are a useful indicator species) show that labeled uses of neonicotinoids do not impact bee-colony health. Although less research has been conducted on other pollinators, studies on bumblebees and leaf-cutting bees have shown that neonicotinoid applications can be safely used without harming these important pollinators.