QSince all stages of GMO conventional agriculture heavily rely on petroleum, how will this affect the price of food and environmental pollution in the long term? If we were to fully embrace GMO conventional wouldn't we be depending dangerously on a raw m

Since all stages of GMO conventional agriculture heavily rely on petroleum, how will this affect the price of food and environmental pollution in the long term? If we were to fully embrace GMO conventional wouldn't we be depending dangerously on a raw material that is getting more rare and increasingly expensive to acquire and process?

AExpert Answer

The facts do not support the idea that GM crops are more heavily reliant on petroleum than conventional or organic crops. One of the largest uses of petroleum in agriculture is for running machinery across fields to mechanically control weeds through tillage operations. Prior to the introduction of GM herbicide-tolerant crops, farmers were already adopting reduced tillage practices, which were made possible with the availability of selective postemergent herbicides that could be used on growing weeds without harming the crop. Since the introduction of GM crops, many studies have shown that the adoption of GM herbicide-tolerant crops has contributed to the increased adoption of reduced tillage systems.1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7 By contrast, organic growers are heavily reliant on tillage to control weeds, as the use of synthetic herbicides is prohibited under the USDA organic standard. As a result, organic growers not only use more fuel than growers of conventional and GM crops but cause increased erosion and decreased water retention of soils. Further, the adoption of GM insect-resistant crops has reduced the use of insecticides,8 which reduces the number of passes farmers make to apply insecticides—another major fuel savings.


1 Fernandez-Cornejo, J., C. Hallahan, R. Nehring, S. Wechsler and A. Grube, 2012, “Conservation Tillage, Herbicide Use, and Genetically Engineered Crops in the United States: The Case of Soybeans,” AgBioForum, vol. 15, no. 3, pp. 231-241.


2 Towery, D., and S. Werblow, 2010,Facilitating Conservation Farming Practices and Enhancing Environmental Sustainability with Agricultural Biotechnology, Conservation Tillage Information Center, West Lafayette, IN.


3 English, B.C., Q. Chi, R.K. Roberts and J. Larson, 2005, “The Use of Bayes’ Theorem to Explore the Adoption of Herbicide-Tolerant cotton Seed and No-Tillage Production Practices,” Proceedings of the 27th Southern Conservation Tillage Systems Conference, Florence, South Carolina, 27-29 June, pp. 42-46.


4 Givens, W.A., D.R. Shaw, G.R. Kruger, W.G. Johnson, S.C. Weller, B.G. Young, et al., 2009, “Survey of tillage trends following the adoption of glyphosate-resistant crops,” Weed Technology, vol. 23, pp. 150-55.


5 Marra, M.C., N.E. Piggott and G.A. Carlson, 2004, The net benefits, including convenience, of roundup ready soybeans: results from a national survey, National Science Foundation Center for Integrated Pest Management, Raleigh, NC.


6 Roberts, R.K., B.C. English, Q. Gao and J.A. Larson, 2006, “Simultaneous adoption of herbicide-resistance and conservation-tillage cotton technologies,” Journal of Agricultural and Applied Economics , vol. 38, pp. 629-43.


7 Frisvold, G.B., A. Boor and J.M. Reeves, 2009, “Simultaneous diffusion of herbicide resistant cotton and conservation tillage,” AgBioForum, vol. 12, pp. 249-57.


8 Brookes, G. and P. Barfoot, 2013, “Key environmental impacts of global genetically modified (GM) crop use 1996-2011,” GM Crops and Food, vol. 4, no. 2, pp. 109-119.

Posted on May 6, 2018
The UPC (Universal Product Code) is a barcode (which has numbers beneath it) which identifies the product and the manufacturer. I think you may be thinking of the PLU (Price Look Up) code which is the 4 or 5 digit number on produce used to link a price with an item. The PLU code is a voluntary program that assigns numbers to produce items, this helps cashiers identify the correct price for a produce item. Growers/Packers can use the number "9" prefix to this 4-digit numeric code to... Read More
Posted on May 10, 2017
The simple answer is that 20+ years of composition assessments of GMO crops have demonstrated that crop composition is not appreciably affected by the GM process (1). In addition, data collected through that time have indicated that general factors such as the growth environment can contribute to notable variation in component levels (2). Plant agglutinins (or lectins) and amylase inhibitors are examples of anti-nutritional compounds that may be present in crops. The relevance of such a... Read More
Posted on March 2, 2018
Believe it or not, I jump at opportunities to talk about aquatic life, so thank you for your interest. I developed a passion for aquatic animals early on and remain grateful that I have managed to explore my passions in ecotoxicology for over 25 years! This is a very general question in terms of pesticide/herbicide options that are commercially available and as well as applications. I will focus on glyphosate and dicamba specifically. Two active ingredients in herbicidal formulations that... Read More

Explore More Topics