QIf no proof has been found that GMOs are harmful to humans, then why are they banned in some countries?

If no proof has been found that GMOs are harmful to humans, then why are they banned in some countries?

AExpert Answer

GMO crops are not "banned" in any countries around the world in the normal sense of that word. Usually when something is banned for consumption, etc., it is because some problem emerged that needed a response. The history of regulation for biotech crops is quite different in that there were regulatory approval processes developed long before any such crops were commercialized. The goal was to try to anticipate any potential health or environmental issues and to make sure that no such problems were encountered. In the U.S. a "Coordinated Framework" for crop biotechnology regulation was set up with specific oversight responsibilities for the USDA, the EPA and the FDA. Other countries set up their own regulatory protocols. The goal was to ensure safety, and if any real safety issues had emerged after initial approvals, the system would have responded with a ban or some other restriction. In more than 20 years that has not been necessary. 


Even well before any commercializations, there were activist groups that were opposed to the technology. Not for scientific issues, but primarily in opposition from a more philosophical position (anti-corporate. etc.) Those parties had different levels of influence from country to country depending on the degree to which politics drives regulation in each region. In much of Europe, very few farmers ever ended up being able to use these technologies and foods had to be labeled if they contained "GMO ingredients." In Europe many food industry players have chosen not to include GM ingredients, but that has been on a voluntary basis, not because of any governmental "ban." In Europe, GM crops were typically allowed, at least on a case-by-case basis as animal feeds and large quantities of such crops have since been imported from the countries where the farmers are allowed to grow them.


In the developing world there have been a number of successful campaigns by anti-GMO crops to block the production and even the import of GM crops and foods. Once again, these campaigns have not been driven by legitimate scientific questions and in many cases have been promoted by claims that are demonstrably false.


After more than two decades of commercialization without any health issues, the scientific community has been encouraging a streamlining of the regulatory process and a shift towards one the focuses more on the "product" itself than the "process" by which it was developed.  Unfortunately, politics will continue to play a major role, particularly in some regions.


Posted on July 4, 2018
Thank you for your questions, we will address each question separately below. How is a transgenic organism or GMO created? When people refer to Genetically Modified Organisms (GMOs), they are referring to precision plant breeding using genetic engineering. It allows plant breeders to take a desirable trait (like resistance to drought, insects, weeds, and disease) from one plant or organism and transfer it to the plant they want to improve, as well as make... Read More
Posted on May 7, 2018
Hi and thanks for the question! I think you may have been inspired by recent reports on the discovery of the human gene PDE10A. This gene helps the Bajau people (a marine hunter-gatherer people living in southeast Asia) dive deeper and for greater duration. This genetic adaption increases the size of their spleen, which helps the Bajau perform in low-oxygen environments. At the same time, new techniques for editing DNA (of all organisms) has many people excited about curing human genetic... Read More
Posted on March 2, 2018
Believe it or not, I jump at opportunities to talk about aquatic life, so thank you for your interest. I developed a passion for aquatic animals early on and remain grateful that I have managed to explore my passions in ecotoxicology for over 25 years! This is a very general question in terms of pesticide/herbicide options that are commercially available and as well as applications. I will focus on glyphosate and dicamba specifically. Two active ingredients in herbicidal formulations that... Read More